Selion Perspective
Twenty Years of Mistakes, Suddenly Valuable
The work that formed a leader’s judgment is being automated away. Why experience is becoming the scarce asset.
Judgment is the most valuable thing a senior leader has, and the hardest to see. It is the sense of which risk is worth taking and which only looks brave. No one is born with it. It is made, over time.
It was made in unglamorous ways. A person spent their twenties and much of their thirties on work beneath the job they would one day hold. Like the analysis nobody senior wanted to run. The first draft that came back covered in red. The client call that went wrong, and the apology rehearsed in the lift the next morning. The value was never the work itself. It was what the work left behind: a long private record of what goes wrong and why, built one mistake at a time. By the time someone reached a position where judgment was expected of them, they had it. Nobody had taught it to them. They had earned it, and in most cases by getting things wrong.
That apprenticeship is now being taken apart. At first it looks like progress.
The lower rungs are thinning
The work that trained the young is the work the new tools do first. The most careful studies, of payroll records in the United States and of hiring data in the United Kingdom and across more than forty countries, find the same thing. Among people in their early twenties, employment in the jobs most exposed to these tools has fallen well below where it would otherwise be. Their older colleagues in the same jobs have held steady, and often grown. The economists are careful, and rightly. They find no general collapse in work, and they say other forces are mixed into the numbers. But the pattern is specific. The fall lands almost entirely on the youngest, in work that rests on knowledge that can be written down and therefore learned by a machine. The experienced are spared. It sits in the person, and a machine has no way in.
There is a second effect, and it is more disguised. Even where the young are still hired, the way they used to become good is being smoothed away. A peer-reviewed study from a Swiss business school last year looked at how people actually use these tools. The heavier the reliance, the weaker the habit of thinking for oneself. The loss was greatest in those who had leaned on the machine before they had formed much of their own. More schooling and more experience gave some protection. It is only a correlation, but also hard to dismiss. The friction now being removed with such enthusiasm, the struggle with a blank page, the long way round a problem that a tool can now skip, was never waste. It was the forge.
The thinking that makes it
It is worth being exact about what is at risk. The machine has knowledge in abundance; that was never the scarce part. What forms judgment is a handful of ways of thinking that only develop by being used. The thinking that happens in conversation, reading the person across the table and adjusting what was about to be said. The thinking of deliberation, when the evidence is incomplete and the uncertainty has to be held long enough to weigh it rather than flee it. The thinking that produces something new, the connection that arrives sideways and could not have been reasoned to in a straight line. And the plain, stubborn thinking of working a problem through after the first three answers were wrong. Each of these is a muscle, built by repetition with something real at stake. And each is exactly what the machine now offers to do for the young, before they have done it enough times for themselves.
The chemist and philosopher Michael Polanyi put it in eight words sixty years ago: we can know more than we can tell. The most important things an expert knows, he argued, cannot be reduced to instructions, which is why they cannot be handed over in a manual and have to be absorbed through practice. Ikujiro Nonaka, whose work on how knowledge is created inside companies grew out of a close study of Japanese firms, made the same point about organisations. Tacit knowledge passes between people mainly through shared experience, the way it always moved from master to apprentice, by watching, imitating, trying and failing in company. It cannot be downloaded. If you remove the shared doing, the knowledge simply stops moving.
Formed judgment, once it exists, is not hard to recognise. It shows less in what a person claims than in what they reach for first: the question about what went wrong last time, asked before any question about the plan. A readiness to say that something is not yet clear, in a culture that rewards looking certain. A way of listening that notices who has gone quiet. It fits on no CV, which is why it is so often passed over for the credential that does.
And there is something that only becomes obvious with age. The part of judgment that matters most, in the end, is the creative part. The capacity to see a problem from an angle no one in the meeting expected, to find the way through that was on nobody's list. It is the rarest kind of thinking and the hardest to develop, because it cannot be drilled, only nurtured, and grown. It is also the part the machine most eagerly offers to do instead. Which makes it the part most at risk of never forming in the generation now starting out.
The asset that is appreciating
The usual thing a leader in the middle of a career is told to feel about all this is a low-grade dread. That their experience is losing value under them. That they had better retrain quickly as something called AI-fluent before the same wave reaches their own rung. There is an argument for reading it almost the other way. If judgment is becoming harder to make, then judgment already made is becoming scarcer, and what is scarce does not fall in value. The person in their late forties or early fifties who learned the slow way, and who has the private record of failures, scars, and the feel for people that came with it, holds something the market has not finished repricing. It is gaining value while they worry about it.
The executives at that stage who seem most at ease have stopped apologising for how long it took them to get good. They treat that long formation as the uncommon thing it has become. They have mostly stopped chasing badges in the new tools. Some have gone a step further. The organisations that will still have leaders to call on in a decade are the ones still turning the young into the experienced, still paying for the unglamorous work that forms people even when a machine could do that same work faster. Whoever keeps the apprenticeship alive, across a whole firm or a single team, will hold a supply of judgment their competitors let run dry. The leader who can still form other leaders may prove the most valuable person in the building.
The pressure is sharpest in the West, where performance is counted by the quarter and the junior who costs more than the tool is the first saving anyone reaches for. Owners who think in generations have always been readier to pay for formation that shows up in no current account, because they expect to be there in fifteen years to collect on it. That patience used to look like sentiment. It is turning into an edge. And empowerment.
But none of this asks a leader to romanticise difficulty, or to deny their people the tools everyone else now has.
The question underneath is narrower and much more awkward. When the machine takes the task that used to teach, what teaches in its place?
A few companies, not many, are beginning to ask it seriously. They are redesigning early work so that a person still has to reason before the tool is allowed to answer, and still has to live with a real consequence rather than a simulated one. Most are not asking at all. They will notice the gap only when they reach for the next generation of leaders and find the shelf thinner than the strategy plan assumed.
Some years from now, when the shortage of formed judgment has moved from forecast to fact, the people who have it will not need to argue their worth. Many have it already, without quite registering that the ground has tilted their way. The question worth sitting with, for anyone running a business or hoping to, is where that judgment actually lives, who still holds it, and who is still being given the slow, unimpressive work that makes more of it. Those are answerable questions, though the organisation chart will not answer them, and neither will a quarter's numbers. They are also, in all likelihood, the ones on which the next decade of leadership will turn.