Selion Perspective

The Sideways Years

The part of a senior career that reads worst on paper is often the part that did the most work.

The part of a senior career that reads worst on paper is often the part that did the most work.

We are still not certain how to make the case cleanly in conversation. Someone who moved once between industries, or spent three years inside a business that was being taken apart, or left a functional track at forty-two to run something small and unfamiliar, presents on the page as a person with an explanation to give. The unbroken career has nothing to explain. Those two are not being interpreted on the same terms, and the difference has less to do with capability than we would like to admit.

By pivot we mean the mid-career kind. In other words, a change of function, sector, ownership model or market made by someone already senior enough to have had something to lose. The reasons are usually mixed and some of them never go in writing. A business was sold. A chairman who made the work impossible. A parent falling ill in another country. Even curiosity, that thirst to expand the horizon, which is the motive people are most embarrassed to name.

There is decent evidence that this shape of career produces something distinctive. A longitudinal study of Fortune 250 chief executives, published in the Academy of Management Journal in 2014, put a name to it: career variety, the range of separate professional and institutional experiences a person accumulates before taking the top job. Variety turned out to be associated with strategic novelty afterwards. More change period on period, and more deviation from whatever the rest of the industry was doing. Research published in Management Science five years later found something adjacent. Firms led by chief executives who had built general, transferable managerial skill across their working lives filed more patents, and those patents were cited more often.

What is happening is that the meaning has not finished arriving

We want to be careful here, because the finding people want is not quite the finding that exists. This work does not show that such chief executives simply perform better. In the 2019 study the relationship between general managerial skill and firm performance was positive and statistically insignificant, which is a courteous way of saying the data would not lift the weight. What the evidence supports is narrower and, we think, more useful. The varied career predicts a particular kind of leadership, one that departs from the industry's central tendency. That is worth a great deal in a business that has to change. It is worth rather less in one that needs three years with less noise on the radar.

Then there is this. An earlier study by the same authors, built from the résumés of chief executives at fifteen hundred US listed companies, found generalists were paid around nineteen per cent more a year than specialists. So the market has been paying a premium for the varied career for over a decade. The screening, further upstream, has not caught up. Our own sense, held loosely here, is that the pivot does most of its damage early, before anyone has spoken to the person.

Some of this is the form itself. A CV is chronological and a pivot is not a chronological argument, it is a retrospective one. It only makes sense read in the direction the person cannot yet write. Someone three years into a change has made the decision but does not yet have the sentence for it. They over-explain, which often reads as defensiveness, or skate past it, which is interpreted as something being kept back. But neither is what is actually happening. What is happening is that the meaning is emerging and has not finished arriving.

And at the other end of the life, the unconventional start creates a similar problem. A first decade that looks like drift, or like a different profession altogether, sits badly against a page that rewards early recognition. In our experience, people who found their real work late are often unusually good at it, and unusually calm about it, having already discovered what they did not want. That calm is difficult to see on a CV. It shows up in person.

And some of this is simply where the reader is standing. In the United States, median tenure with an employer was 3.9 years in January 2024, the shortest since 2002. Four employers in twelve years is unremarkable there. And looking East, Singapore has moved the other way: the share of employed residents who changed jobs in the past year fell from 7.6 per cent in 2024 to 6.2 per cent in 2025. The same career, carried between the two markets, is interpreted against two different baselines by a reader who often doesn't realise that they are holding one. The Singapore figure has a second half worth looking at. Of those who did move, six in ten saw real income rise, against roughly one in four of those who stayed a full year with the same employer. Movement has been where the gains were, and it is also the thing that looks like risk on a page.

The executives who carry a pivot well do not defend it. They can say what the change was for, what it cost them, what they now understand that they would not otherwise understand. That move is standing as a decision rather than as weather. They also resist the opposite failure, which is treating a varied career as a merit in itself. Movement is not range. A person who has been in six places in nine years and cannot tell you what any of them taught has a different problem, and it is a real one.

For those of you doing the reading, the question that gets somewhere is seldom why did you leave. It is what you learned there that you could not have learned by staying. If the answer is thin after three years in an unfamiliar world, that tells you something you needed to know. In our experience the answer is not usually thin.

The shape of career we have learned to trust was produced by conditions that have gone. What came after made a rougher kind of career, and those people are on your longlist already. Further down. There is a line on their page nobody has thought to ask about.