© Unsplash + license

Selion Perspective

The Wrong Fight Arrives Well Dressed

The most expensive asset in any business is its leader's attention, and by the one process nobody audits: appetite.

Ask where a company's strategy lives and someone will hand you a document. Watch the company for a year instead and the strategy turns out to live somewhere less tidy, in the fights its chief executive agrees to have. The acquisition pursued a little past the point of prudence, or the argument with a regulator that ran a season longer than the point required. A plan records what a business intends. The fights record what its leader finds irresistible, and the two lists agree less often than the annual report suggests.

We spend our working lives close to the moment a leader says yes. What has come to interest us, is how seldom that yes is examined by anyone, including the person giving it. A no has to be argued for, most often defended, and minuted. Nobody has ever been asked to justify their appetite.

Where the appetite comes from

It was built honestly, and this is what makes it hard to see. Early in a career, the difficult assignment is the only currency available to someone without a record. You take the market nobody wants, or the integration everyone expects to fail, and each one pays out twice, once in results and once in reputation. And somewhere in those years, saying yes to the hard thing and exercising good judgement become the same motion. They are the same motion, then. The yes is how a leader gets made, and anyone reading this who spent twenty years running at closed doors did precisely what the situation asked of them. So, for what it is worth, did we.

The trouble arrives later and makes no sound. At some point, usually well after the point at which anything still needed proving, appetite and judgement part company without much ceremony. The instinct goes on firing with much enthusiasm, and is simply answering an old question. The fights it selects are the ones that would have made the leader of 1998, and it selects them beautifully.

Nobody is paid to ask

It would be convenient to blame the people around the leader for this, and it would be wrong. Consider what a chief executive's diary is actually made of. Almost everyone who brings a fight to it does better when the answer is yes. The banker's fee depends on it, and so, rather less visibly, does the next role of the deputy who proposed the campaign. A board under pressure tends to sleep better behind a leader visibly at war, because activity photographs well and restraint barely photographs at all. None of this is bad faith. It is simply that a leader's appetite is the most monetised thing in the building, and monetised things are not questioned by the people they pay.

“A leader's appetite is the most monetised thing in the building, and monetised things are not questioned by the people they pay.”

Which leaves one person with a standing reason to examine the yes: the person giving it, who is also the person the reflex belongs to. That is by no means a flaw in anybody's character. It is a gap in the structure, and structures do not mend themselves.

What the strongest decline

We notice the difference most in what never happens.

The strongest leaders we have worked near are not the ones who fight less. Several fight constantly and enjoy it without the slightest embarrassment. What sets them apart is a question they put to a fight before accepting it, which runs roughly: what would winning this prove, and to whom. A surprising number of tempting fights fail it. Winning them would prove something proven long ago to an audience that stopped needing convincing around the time of the second big win.

They have also learned to distrust how a challenge is dressed. The wrong fight tends to arrive beautifully turned out, with a precedent to cite and an audience already seated, and a shape of victory everyone can picture in advance. But the right one, at this height of a career, usually shows itself shapeless. No applause has been arranged for it and there is no guarantee it can be won, which is exactly why the old reflex walks straight past it on the way to something better lit.

And the ones who take the point furthest treat the pattern of their own yeses as a public document, because inside the company that is what it is. Two layers down, people study what the chief executive fights about far more attentively than they read anything the chief executive writes. The accepted fights are the actual curriculum of the business and taught daily, but examined never. A head of people who wants to know what leadership model the organisation is really teaching could do worse than list the last ten fights the top of the house took on, and ask what a clever thirty-five-year-old would conclude from the list.

There is a second thing that list would show, and it matters more with every year the veteran pool thins. Which fights a chief executive keeps and which they hand down is also where the next leaders get made, or not. A worthwhile fight given away, with real stakes still attached, does more for a rising leader than any programme yet devised. A leader who keeps every good fight for themselves is running a business that will one day go shopping for exactly what it declined to grow.

The larger bet

None of this argues for temperance. That would be a dull conclusion, and an unearned one. It argues that declining has become the more ambitious act of the two. Every yes spends the scarcest thing the business owns, and spends it in public. The leader who turns down a fight that merely flatters them is not conserving anything; they are keeping the diary open for the one that will need everything they have since become, and betting, in front of everyone, that it is coming.

We will admit the question underneath all this is an awkward one to place. Which fights are truly yours to take is about as consequential as questions get, and it has no natural venue, because everyone who might raise it sits somewhere inside the structure it examines. It tends to be asked late, rather alone, or not at all.

Few bets say more about a leader. Fewer still are watched more closely by the people deciding what kind of leader to become.