Selion Perspective
The Market That Stopped Making CEOs
Something unusual happened at the top of American companies last year, and it is worth reflecting before drawing conclusions from it. More public-company chief executives left their posts in 2025 than in any year since anyone began keeping the record. Challenger, Gray & Christmas, which has tracked these departures since 2002, counted 446, up from 373 the year before. A great deal of movement, then. What is odd is how little of it produced a new leader.
We watch this from between Europe and Asia, and part of what makes the pattern legible from here is that it does not travel everywhere. It is a Western condition, and among the founder-led and family-held businesses of Asia it largely stops. We will come to why, because the difference turns out to explain a good deal.
What we think is happening
When a role comes open now, it tends to be filled by someone who has sat in such seat before. The proven outsider, the returning veteran, or the executive whose name a board already recognises. Where a first-time appointment might once have been made, a company increasingly reaches for a placeholder instead, an interim, and waits. And the leaders who are neither leaving nor being replaced are simply staying, later into their sixties than their predecessors did, in numbers that would have seemed unusual a decade ago.
Certainly, none of this is irrational, and we should say so plainly, because the pressure behind it is real. A board today operates under a scrutiny that would have been unfamiliar a generation ago, with activist investors quicker to campaign and quicker to be noted, and a chief executive often given a quarter or two to show results before patience runs short. Under that kind of watch, the appeal of a known quantity is easy to understand. We would feel it too.
But watch enough of these appointments and something underneath the caution begins to show. Boards will tell you they are buying readiness, that means a leader who can perform from the first week without an apprenticeship, and often that is exactly what they are buying. What a proven name also buys, underneath, is calm. A name that has done the job before is easy to defend to an anxious shareholder, understandably. Conviction about someone not yet tested at the top is harder to put into words, and harder to defend when the decisions become uneasy.
We say this without much reproach. Some of these appointments will be excellent, and the outside hire and the second act are real goods; a fair share of the finest tenures in business began as one or the other. Our interest is less in any single decision than in what the decisions add up to, because the habit has a way of somewhat compounding. The more unforgiving the moment for a stumble, the harder it becomes to give anyone a first attempt at the top. The fewer first attempts, the shallower the pool of the proven, the harder that pool is fought over, and the more natural it feels, the next time, to hold the incumbent or borrow a veteran rather than back someone new. Slowly, and with sound reasons at every step, a market can find it has half stopped producing the very thing it most depends on.
What is underneath
There is a demographic tide underneath all this that will not recede. The generation that has held so many of these seats is reaching the age at which it steps down, and the retirement wave now moving through the Western workforce reaches the corner office as surely as anywhere else. For a while, holding on and bringing back has disguised the gap. It will not indefinitely.
Which is where we find the more interesting thought, and the one we would put to any leader reading this. When a market grows reluctant to make something it relies on, the few who keep making it are handed an advantage. Capital is abundant just now, and most technology can be bought. A leader ready to run something large is neither abundant nor for sale, and cannot be produced quickly; the making of one takes the better part of a decade. The companies that go on making them while their competitors bid against each other for a shrinking supply, will keep something increasingly scarce precisely when it is dearest. The window to become such a company is open now and few are stepping through it, which is exactly what makes it worth doing.
Where leaders are actually made
It is conventional to say the board owns succession, and every governance survey repeats it. In practice, boards ratify succession more than they author it. The choices that decide whether a company grows its own chief executives are made earlier and deeper inside the business as well, and they belong to the chief executive and the head of people, though they seldom announce themselves as succession at all. They surface looking like ordinary questions of who gets what. Who is handed the difficult market and who the safe one. Whose profit line is truly their own and whose is lent to them. Who is put in front of investors, and who is kept from them. These are among the most consequential decisions a chief executive makes, and among the least examined, because none of them have a label saying that a future leader is being formed here, or simply set aside.
Seen that way, what the strongest owners do differently comes into view, and it reflects less as a talent practice than as a way of growing.
They keep a bench as capacity rather than insurance. A plan kept as insurance sits in a drawer and loses value; a bench built as capacity is what lets a company take the acquisition a rival cannot easily digest, or move on the opening that appears mid-cycle, because the leader for it is already made and already there. The businesses that compound fastest are almost never the ones with the most polished strategy. More often they are the ones that can field a ready leader faster than the market can supply one, which at the moment is not difficult, since the market has largely stopped supplying them.
They notice what everyone else's caution has left lying in plain sight. Every company reaching for a proven outsider is, at the same time, asking its own strongest rising leaders to wait. Those people, the ones with real profit lines behind them and a decade still ahead, are being marked down by their employers' nerves, and are within reach of anyone able to offer the one thing they cannot get where they are: the seat, or a credible path to it. Some of the most rewarding appointments we see happen here, among leaders another organisation had decided not to look at closely. That is a market that misprices its best people and is an invitation, and it does not stay open forever.
And they widen where leaders are made, not only where they are found. The formative postings and the hard market, or the first real meeting with investors, cost very little and pay in the one currency that will be scarce when the veteran pool finally thins. A chief executive who this year gives three rising leaders genuinely exposed responsibility has done more for where the company stands in 2033 than any succession memorandum will.
The border, and the bet
This is roughly where the Western pattern stops, namely at the edge of the founder-led and family-held companies of Asia, and the reason is worth to think a little more about. An owner who means to hold a business for a generation, when appointing a leader, is buying that leader's next fifteen years. A committee answering to the current quarter is buying its own composure. They are shopping for different things and only one of them is really building. It is not that one culture is wiser than the other. It is that patience is easier to afford when the horizon is long, and most Western boards no longer feel they have a long horizon.
There is a particular type of leader this whole argument has been circling. Somewhere in a large business sits a capable executive, mid-career, told for years in the way these things are told that the top is coming, now watching it go instead to someone from outside. If that is you, a plain word, meant well. Patience is now a strategy with a falling return. What boards reach for under much pressure is not depth or loyalty but legibility, a profit line visibly your own, some scar tissue from the capital markets, a record a nervous decision-maker can point to. Where your own company will not give you these, the queue ahead of you is ageing in place, and the first real seat, when it comes, is now at least as likely to come from a founder handing over, or an investor-backed business that prizes upside over reassurance.
Sometime in the early 2030s, a good many boards will sit down to replace a chief executive and find the veterans gone and a ready leader priced accordingly. The companies that pass through that moment without losing a step are deciding it now, in appointments too small to reach a board agenda and too easy to defer. The advantage is still there for the taking, and it is not expensive, and for the moment very few are reaching for it.