Selion Perspective
Appointments Are Easy.
Arrivals Are Not.
A reflection on senior appointments, leadership transition, and the architecture of arrival.
A Selion Perspective
The announcement goes out on a Tuesday. The press release reads exactly as you would expect, the photograph is the one taken eighteen months ago for the annual report, and within an hour the appointment has crossed three time zones. The board exhales. The search firm sends a note. The new CEO replies to two hundred LinkedIn messages over the weekend and arrives on Monday morning, on time, in the office that is now hers.
This is the moment most people consider the work to be finished. We have come to think it is the moment the work begins.
In the appointments we have watched closely over thirty years — and we have watched a great many — the first eighteen months tell you almost everything about whether the company gets the CEO it thought it was hiring. The search matters. The interviews matter. The references, the diagnostic tests, taken carefully, all of it matters. But the period that decides the outcome is the one nobody plans for: the eighteen months after the announcement, during which the new CEO is doing two jobs at once. The visible one, which the market is watching. And the invisible one, which almost nobody is. The invisible job is the arrival — the slow, mostly private work of becoming the person the role requires, in a company and a context that have not yet decided whether to let her.
This work is not done in solitude. Most new CEOs are surrounded by capable people. There is a board. There is an executive team. There are advisors, mentors, peers from earlier chapters. What is missing is not company. What is missing, in our experience, is the particular kind of voice the new CEO most needs in those months, and the reasons for that absence are structural rather than anyone’s fault.
A chair, however generous, is also the person who hired her. There are conversations she cannot have with him without cost. The executive team is watching her closely, taking its cues from her judgement, but it is not their place to support her through what she is working out. A mentor is useful but rarely available in the moments that are really crucial and count, which tend to arrive on Tuesday evenings rather than during scheduled check-ins. A coach is useful, but coaching tends to work on what someone does, and what the new CEO is doing is figuring out who she is in this seat. Her family knows her but not the role. Her peers from earlier chapters know who she was, not who she is becoming.
What the new CEO actually needs, alongside all of these, is something more specific: a small set of voices, ideally two or three at most, who have sat in the seat or close to it, who carry no agenda inside her company, and who can be reached on a weekend. People who can tell her what she cannot see, which is almost always the thing she most needs to know. This is not mentorship, and it is not coaching. It is closer to what the diplomat Tommy Koh once described, in a different context, as the work of trusted intermediaries, people whose value lies precisely in their distance from the immediate stakes.
There isn't yet a settled language for what good accompaniment looks like.
Most boards we work with are doing more of this than they once did. The conversation about onboarding has matured considerably over the last decade. What we still see, fairly often, is the gap between the seriousness with which the search itself is conducted and the relative lightness of the planning for what follows. Months are spent on the appointment. Weeks are sometimes spent on compensation. The thinking around the first eighteen months — who the CEO can reach out to, in what register, about which kinds of question — is often left to improvisation. Sometimes the improvisation works. Sometimes it doesn’t, often eighteen months later, and no one can quite say when the turn happened.
We do not think any of this is the board’s failing. It is, more often, a gap in the convention. There isn’t yet a settled language for what good accompaniment looks like, and so the question gets handled piece by piece, depending on the chair, the company, the moment. We have learned a great deal from the boards we have worked with on this, and we are still learning.
There is one variant of this pattern where the work becomes acute, and it is the appointment that crosses regions. The European CEO who has held a global role from London or Copenhagen, with regional responsibility for Asia from a distance, and who is now asked to run the business from inside it. The Asian executive elevated to a group role in Frankfurt or Paris. The American hire whose remit covers a region she has visited, perhaps frequently, but never lived in. These appointments now make up a meaningful share of the senior moves we are asked to support, and the failure rate is higher than the published numbers suggest, because most failures are recorded as something else. A strategic reset. A change in market conditions. A mutual decision.
What is actually happening, in many of these cases, is that the new CEO is doing the arrival twice. She is recalibrating into the role, and she is recalibrating into the place. The two run alongside each other, and one slows the other.
Asia is the version of this we know best. An executive with a strong global track record — including, often, prior responsibility for the region from a Western headquarters — arrives in Singapore, Shanghai, or Mumbai expecting her experience to serve her. Much of it does. Some of it does not. The cues she has read confidently for years from a distance look different when she is actually leading on the ground. The dynamics in her first meeting is not assent. The dinner invitation she declined for sensible reasons has been received as a signal she did not intend to send. None of this is in a briefing pack. Most of it is invisible to the people sitting next to her, who have learned that surfacing it is not their place. A year in, the appointment is working. Two years in, the company has formed a view.
The same is true in reverse. An Asian executive moved to a European group role faces a different version of the same problem. The conventions she has spent decades understanding — pace, hierarchy, the etiquette of disagreement, the meaning of silence — operate on a different setting in Frankfurt or Paris, and the recalibration is no less demanding for being in the other direction. We have watched senior Asian leaders described as reserved when they were being precise, and as indirect or even introvert when they were being respectful. The cost of that misreading, compounded over eighteen months, is the same cost the European CEO pays in Singapore. The appointment that should have worked, gradually stops working.
This is the part of our work that does not sit inside the mandate itself. The search ends with the appointment. The arrival, particularly across regions, asks more of the people around the new CEO than any other transition we are asked to support.
What we have come to believe, watching this pattern across many appointments and many places, is that the boards who get this right have stopped treating the appointment as the end of their work, but treat it as the opening move. They take the first eighteen months as seriously as they take the search. They think early and deliberately about who the new CEO will be able to call. Those voices that have no agenda inside the company, those that have sat close to the seat, and that can be reached on a weekend. And in the cross-regional appointment, they build that set knowing the recalibration is double, and that one of the voices probably needs to be someone who has lived inside the new place, not only studied it.
None of this is settled practice. The firms we admire most on this question — and we have learned from many of them — are working it out alongside us. The convention is shifting, and the expectations boards bring to this work are higher than they were five years ago.
The press release is the easy part, and it is also the part everyone celebrates. The work that decides whether the celebration was deserved happens later, more behind closed doors, in conversations the market never sees.
This is one of the patterns we watch for.