Selion Perspective
When Boards Look at Themselves - A Peek Beyond Ritual and Toward Renewal
Every year, boards across the world evaluate their performance. The exercise has become almost universal, codified into governance codes and annual reports. Questionnaires are circulated, one-on-one interviews are conducted, and an external assessor is sometimes brought in to give structure and independence. The findings are presented, noted, and often filed away until the cycle begins again.
And yet, anyone who has sat in a boardroom knows how much of this process can remain untouched. Evaluations risk becoming ritual, like a mirror held up politely, and reflecting only what is safe to say. The undercurrents that matter most, the dominance of a chair perhaps, the marginalisation of one or two directors, the factions formed behind tenure and status, rarely find their way into a report. One director confided during a debrief: “We are satisfied with our board work as a whole. We are just not satisfied with each other.”
This is the paradox of evaluation: structurally sound, procedurally correct, yet culturally evasive.
Most boards pride themselves on civility. Collegiality is placed centre stage, while open conflict is frowned upon. But civility, though a valuable element, can act as a lid on being open. Polite exchanges often conceal conflictual relationships that shape outcomes. The real test of evaluation is whether it can surface what is unsaid without fracturing trust.
In leadership studies, Manfred Kets de Vries, the Dutch psychoanalyst and long-time professor at INSEAD, and widely recognised for his work on the psychology of leadership, has written extensively about these “shadow sides”: the rivalries, the egos and tensions that exist beneath polished interactions. Reflecting on years of board advisory, Boards are no exception. Behind the shield of order often lie conflicts of status and style. An effective evaluation should not pretend these dynamics are absent. Instead, it should recognise them and ensure they do not corrode collective judgment.
An experienced assessor also notices what the board itself overlooks. The micro-signals, carefully chosen words that sound very polished but lack substance; the lines delivered smoothly yet never answer the question; the vacuum that is slightly hanging in the air, or the phrases that feel too polished. A trained ear hears not only what is said, but how it is said and, in that context, what is deliberately left unsaid.
Of course, directors know they are being assessed. And it is this very awareness that can turn dialogue into performance, with answers delivered for optics rather than honesty. Much of what happens in an evaluation is theatre. Yet theatre itself is revealing; the roles directors choose to play, the lines rehearsed, the unease when the script is disturbed by surprises that were never rehearsed. These performances, if observed with care, become as instructive as the answers themselves.
The process is not without risk. What if the outcome is not what the Chair expects? What if the evaluation surfaces truths that unsettle cohesion, or reveals weaknesses that others - investors, regulators, activists - might exploit? Some view this as destabilising. In reality, it is preparation. An evaluation that merely validates is really a missed opportunity. A serious one stress-tests the board’s cohesion, probes vulnerabilities, and strengthens continuity before external pressures do the same.
Handled well, evaluation equips a board to confront its own shadow side in private before circumstances force it into the open.
And there are examples of evaluations leading to genuine renewal. When Danone’s board was challenged by activist investors, a self-assessment ultimately reshaped its composition and strategy. In several European industrial groups, external evaluations have led to generational renewal, introducing digital or geopolitical expertise because the process surfaced the need.
What emerges from these cases is that evaluation, when taken seriously, becomes less about compliance and more about trust. It allows directors to express what has been sensed but remains unspoken. It reframes interpersonal tensions as pointers for adjustment rather than failings. And it gives Chairs a mirror not only of the board’s collective work, but of how their own leadership is received.
For those who conduct such evaluations, the responsibility is considerable. We are invited into a group where power, reputation, and psychology converge. Our role is to create a space where honesty is possible without damage, where discomfort can be voiced without causing harm, and where the board leaves not only with a report, but with renewed confidence in itself. In this sense, the assessor is less an auditor than a custodian. You may also look at the advisor as a discreet matchmaker ensuring the board is fit to carry the organisation into its next chapter.
Which brings us to the larger question: what is a board for? Jeffrey Sonnenfeld, the Yale professor who has studied boards for decades, argues that great boards are not defined by structure but by spirit, by trust, truthfulness, and shared responsibility. Evaluation, in this light, is not bureaucracy. It is the discipline of checking whether that spirit still lives in the (board)room.
Board evaluation, then, is not business as usual. Done poorly, it sustains illusions. Done well, it becomes a catalyst for stewardship, not only of the company, but of governance itself.
History has a long memory, and shareholders, an even shorter one. Both will remember how the board chose to see itself.